Sanity In Scotland…Country Shoots Down Plans To Build Three Major Windparks In Highlands

While Vermonters in my homestate aren’t proud enough of their beautiful mountains to preserve them, and so have decided to install wind-parks on ridgelines, see here and here, Scotland has decided they want no part of such lunacy.

Must be the fine whisky Scots produce and drink there. They ought to send some of those spirits over to Vermont.

Loch Maree

Loch Maree. Photo credit: Roger McLachlan, Creative Commons Attribution Share-alike license 2.0.

Renewable energy website Recharge here writes that the “Highland Council planners shot down three high-profile projects totalling nearly 80 turbines in a two-day rout for developers”. It’s good to see there is still some environmental sanity left on the planet.

According to the press release at the Mountaineering Council of Scotland website (Feb 12):

The MCofS welcomed the news today that The Highland Council North Planning Committee decided to reject 2 massive onshore wind farm planning proposals.

The section 36 proposals which were determined today are:

· Glemorie Wind Farm: to the north of Dingwall with a proposed 34 turbines and 35 kilometres of access track. The MCofS originally objected to the proposal because it contravenes The Highland Council’s own policy on onshore wind farm locations.

· Dalnessie Wind Farm: 13 km North East of Lairg comprising 27 wind turbines and associated infrastructure, including 20 km of new access track. Each turbine would be up to 121 metres high to blade tip. The MCofS originally objected to the development because it would not be in accordance with the Highland Council’s Development Plan

David Gibson, MCofS Chief Officer stated:

‘We objected to these industrial-scale proposals on the grounds that they were inappropriate developments which contravened Highland Council planning policy; they would have a significant visual impact on the mountains and other wild land, and adversely affect a broad swathe of Scotland’s finest landscapes.’

‘We believe that members of the Planning Committee have acted in the best interests of their constituents, and in the broader public interest, as custodians of some unique and very special landscapes. However, we still fail to understand why Highland Council planning officials originally recommended that the Council should ‘raise no objection’ to Glenmorie and Dalnessie given their own policy and the obvious and intrusive impact on recognised and designated landscape areas.’

‘The MCofS is not opposed to onshore wind farms and we have objected to only 6% of the onshore developments tracked by Scottish Natural Heritage.’

‘We seek protection for the mountains through changes to Scottish Government planning policy. We have called repeatedly for the introduction of a national spatial planning policy for onshore wind farm developments which would give protection to precious mountain landscapes and at the same time offer developers guidance on where wind farms could be located.’

‘The present planning free-for-all, which encourages inappropriate and speculative developments, and in which the Scottish Government is placing unreasonable pressure on local authorities to process and approve developments, is not a recipe for success. The Scottish Government, despite their repeated and empty assurances that such protection exists, must act to provide protection for our superb landscapes. Given this is the Year of Natural Scotland, we believe that is the minimum they should do.’”

This is a refreshing development that hopefully will spread to other regions of the planet. Blasting mountain ridge lines and gouging miles of access roads though forests and landscape in order to soothe environmental paranoia and alleviate irrational fears of a climate catastrophe is environmental lunacy of an unprecedented scale. Unfortunately, places like Vermont have become psychological basket cases in that respect.

Germany has hardly been immune to the insanity. It’s 130 billion in renewable energy investment will theoretically postpone global warming a whole 23 hours, read here. At that rate it would cost the world $4,745,000,000,000,000.00 (4.745 quadrillion) to delay global warming 100 years, provided the dubious theory were true. That’s a million dollars for every family on the planet (if I didn’t lose or gain any zeros in that big number calculation).

It’s truly mind-boggling how easily some people can get carried away by madness. When a few dumb cows start running, the whole herd often follows.

Hats off to Scotland. Maybe I’ll break open that bottle of Doublewood Balvenie I got for Christmas and give a toast.

PS: Sanity also in Vermont’s sister state, New Hampshire: www.sentinelsource.com/antrim-wind-farm-rejected.html. People are waking up! (H/t: David L.)

 

7 responses to “Sanity In Scotland…Country Shoots Down Plans To Build Three Major Windparks In Highlands”

  1. John Shade

    Keep some of that whisky for a future date!

    The issue of these three windfarms has not been settled by the decision of a planing committee of a local council.

    The government in Edinburgh can over-rule that decision, and it is a government that might reasonably be described as crazy about renewables. It has already done a great deal of harm to Scotland with this craziness, and may yet do more. It is being egged-on by a well-connected pressure group calling itself the 2020 Climate Group: http://www.2020climategroup.org.uk/about-2020/the-2020-story/.

    I think there are similar groups elsewhere, e.g. http://www.theclimategroup.org/what-we-do/network/. A mix of business people, government agency workers, and sundry other organisations with a vested interest in pushing ‘renewables’, ‘sustainable development’, ‘low-carbon economy’, and suchlike spin-offs from the climate alarm movement.

    Although that movement may well be sinking in a morass of shoddy and overblown claims, the spin-offs can still hope to distance themselves from it enough to not be dragged down at the same time. The mess that societies around the world will have to clean up thanks to the shocking impact of climate alarmism will not go away even when that alarmism is widely discredited.

    But perhaps, in Scotland, public outcry over the foolishness and destructiveness of windfarms may yet score some early victories and stop some of them being built. The decision of the planners may well deserve a small toast, but it is too early yet to declare a victory.

  2. G. Watkins

    We wait with interest to see the response of the SNP and wee Alec and the pressure from central government, especially the Lib Dims.
    Similar fights are happening in central Wales, with our limited Welsh Assembly pushing hard for the bird mincing windmills.
    BTW great blog I read every day.
    GW

  3. Jeff Wood

    Aye, the council are likely to be overruled, as John points out.

    But enjoy the Balvenie anyway, Pierre.

  4. Recent wind farm rejections….People are finally catching on | Quixotes Last Stand

    [...] Sanity In Scotland…Country Shoots Down Plans To Build Three Major Windparks In Highlands [...]

  5. Neil Jones

    Watch the SNP government overrule this decision.