ALL MEN SHALL BECOME BROTHERS…

Merry Christmas

and a

Happy New Year

NoTricksZone

25 responses to “ALL MEN SHALL BECOME BROTHERS…”

  1. Pointman

    A Happy Christmas to all.

    Pointman

  2. Pops

    A Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year to you too.

  3. nzrobin

    And a merry Christmas to you too Pierre, and all the others who visit here. Wishing you a happy and safe time and all the best for the year ahead. Robin.

  4. John Shade

    Superb performance! Merry Christmas!!

  5. oebele bruinsma

    Thanks Pierre, Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year.

  6. oeman50

    Pierre,

    Your good wishes are gladly accepted and returned to you, my brother.

  7. Edward.

    Reciprocated – PG!

    May all readers here – have a happy Christmas and a most serendipitous new year!

  8. lance

    Merry Christmast everyone.

  9. Ed Caryl

    A Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year to all!

  10. DirkH

    In the original, “Alle Menschen werden Brüder”, which means literally, all Humans become Brothers. Mysogynistic to say the least!

    I am not sure if the author proposes seks-change operations for wymen or den**s their humanity altogether.

    Further study of the text
    http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/9._Sinfonie_%28Beethoven%29
    reveals the piece to be deistic as well, discriminating against European humanists(a.k.a. enlightened/illuminated atheists); and objectifying women (“conquering” a wife).

    Also, the piece maintains the existence of “souls”, again a deeply antimaterialist attitude falling outside the realm of the scientific method.
    Instead of recognizing the universe to be the result of random events, the text maintains the existence of a “creator” and a “plan” for celestial bodies.

    Taken together, it is unbefitting for a postmodern, genderized, secular EU to use the first notes of this piece as their hymn.

    I hope they switch to some twelve-tone, serial, random composition; favorably by a randomly chosen postmodern artist nobody knows or likes, as “liking” is a form of othering.

    May you have an interesting winter holiday.

    1. Mindert Eiting

      Materialism was already a problem in Bach’s time and even two thousand years ago, as he wrote some music to the pre-scientific text ‘Ihr aber seid nicht fleischlich, sondern geistlich, so anders Gottes Geist in euch wohnt.’ In modern English ‘But ye are not in the flesh, but in the spirit, if so be that the Spirit of God dwelleth in you’. Marry Christmas to you Dirk, to Pierre, and all his visitors.

      1. DirkH
    2. Henning Nielsen

      The text is a miracle of beauty, of fellowship and of hope. One of Germany’s greatest gifts to the world.

      1. Loodt Pretorius

        We can argue about that point, Germany’s greatest gifts to the world.

        Benz and Otto for the Diesel engine?
        Christmas trees and Christmas cards?

        I still think it is Silent Night, sung by both sides in the trenches during WWI.

  11. R2Dtoo

    Thank you for all you do. Merry Christmas and the best in 2015, from Canada.

  12. BobW in NC

    Let me add another grateful “Thank you” Pierre for all you do, and a Blessed and Merry Christmas and New Year to all!

  13. John F. Hultquist

    Greetings from central Washington State.
    Sending along a link to our nearby “Bavarian Village”.
    [60 miles north of our house]

    http://leavenworthchristmaslighting.com/

    Logging, railroad, nearly disappeared – then went with tourism.
    http://cityofleavenworth.com/

  14. Ike

    Merry Christmas and a happy new year Pierre.

  15. Bjorn Ramstad

    From Norways snow-white Christmas I also wish you all a Merry Christmas and hopefully a better new year to come.
    It has been a pleasure to read this site that beeing P.G. or comments.

  16. Streetcred

    Merry Christmas to all !

    1. Streetcred

      http://youtu.be/wSpsFJZ2riQ

      Summertime, and the living is easy … from Brisbane, Australia.

      Frohe Weihnachten zu meiner Familie in Wien !

  17. Simon of Swansea

    Merry Christmas Everyone

  18. David Johnson

    Merry Christmas and a happy new year Pierre.