Great Barrier Reef Warming, Coral Bleaching Driven By Cloud Radiative Forcing, Not Humans

For decades Great Barrier Reef (GBR) warming and coral bleaching have often been assumed to be driven by human greenhouse gas emissions and/or El Niño events. But a new study finds a much larger and more robust correlation between natural cloud cover modulation of solar radiation, shallow-water warming, and bleaching.

It has taken over 260 years for the net total radiative forcing from CO2 to allegedly rise by a grand net total of 1.82 W/m².

But a new study reveals that a commonly-observed 20% decrease in cloud cover over the GBR exposes this region to an additional 30 W/m² of direct solar radiation for weeks, months at a time. This dramatically warms shallower waters and, more importantly, the enhanced shortwave radiation perpetually exposes corals to UV bleaching.

“Lagged regional sea surface temperature (SST) is correlated with total cloud cover across the Great Barrier Reef (GBR) and direct shortwave cloud radiative forcing.”
“SST over the GBR is more highly correlated with the overhead cloud cover than the large-scale El Niño–Southern Oscillation signal.”
“Local-scale reduced cloud cover plays a crucial role in the shallow water warming over the GBR and the occurrence of thermal coral bleaching events.”

Image Source: Zhao et al., 2021 (full pdf)

The evidence shows naturally-driven coral bleaching events have been ongoing for centuries, millennia, and beyond.

Earlier this year we highlighted a 2021 study asserting Coral Bleaching ‘Repeatedly Occurred’ Throughout The Warmer-Than-Today Mid-Holocene.

Now, another novel study even uses evidence from 150-year-old paintings to show coral bleaching was commonly observed during the frigid Little Ice Age. Coral bleaching can and often does occur during cold periods and/or in winter (Hoegh-Guldberg and Fine, 2005, Saxby et al., 2003, Hoegh-Guldberg and Fine, 2004).

Image Source: Cedhagen, 2021

The author asserts that what is “widely believed” about human-driven coral bleaching is wholly wrong, as bleaching is “not a modern phenomenon” but a “normal way of adapting to changing water temperatures.” Coral bleaching has been recorded in the 1930s, 1860s (paintings), and 1570s.

“It is widely believed that coral bleaching is a phenomenon first observed less than 50 years ago. However, coral bleaching was first observed more than 150 years ago by Eugen von Ransonnet, during the period called the little ice age (ca. 1300 – ca. 1900).”
“Yonge already in 1931 found that living corals on the Great Barrier Reef were bleached after being exposed to high temperature (Oliver et al. 2009; Yonge and Nicholls 1931), and Kamenos and Hennige (2018) recorded the traces of coral bleaching in coral rock cores from the Great Barrier Reef back to 1575. So, coral bleaching is a phenomenon that always has existed as a normal way of adaptation to changing water temperatures, and is not a modern phenomenon.”

There is even evidence that coral bleaching is more likely to occur where water is cooler. For example, the Coral Triangle is 2-8°C warmer than surrounding “marginal” or “low-temperature” areas, but the cooler regions record more bleaching events than the Coral Triangle does.

“Such coral bleaching during the last decades is reported particularly from marginal lower-temperature areas of the entire distribution area of hermatypic corals (Goreau and Hayes 1994; Oliver et al. 2009; Burke et al. 2011). On the other hand it is generally not, or to a much lower extent, reported from the central area, the so-called Coral Triangle (Oliver et al. 2009; Burke et al. 2011; Ridd 2017), where the water temperature is around 2–8 °C higher and more stable than in the marginal areas (Tchernia 1980; Tomczak and Godfrey 2002).”

So, in sum, yet another claim about the unprecedentedness of modern warming and bleaching in the GBR and their alleged connection to human greenhouse gas emissions has been smeared by observational evidence.

20 responses to “Great Barrier Reef Warming, Coral Bleaching Driven By Cloud Radiative Forcing, Not Humans”

  1. Great Barrier Reef Warming, Coral Bleaching Driven by Cloud Radiative Forcing, Not Humans – Climate- Science.press

    […] Great Barrier Reef Warming, Coral Bleaching Driven By Cloud Radiative Forcing, Not Humans […]

  2. CO2isLife

    I’ve always maintained that if you want to understand global warming you have to understand what is warming the oceans. Visible radiation warms the oceans, not CO2. An additional 30/m^2 is 20x the CO2 back radiation, and 13 to 18 micron LWIR won’t warm the water.

    1. Mike

      I always thought that UV radiation (invisible) is what bleaches most things. Perhaps I’ve been wrong all along?

      1. CO2isLife

        UV, like IR, barely penetrates water, but if UV reaches the coral I’m sure it will far more harm that 15 micron LWIR.

  3. John Hultquist

    ” Visible radiation ”

    Bingo!
    Colors under the surface = visible.

    1. CO2isLife

      Thanks I’ve been saying the quantum physics of the CO2 molecule doesn’t support the warming claims, but no one seemed to understand what I was talking about. If the coral is bleaching, you have to demonstrate that LWIR between 13 and 18 micron can actually reach the coral. It doesn’t. Visible radiation bleaches things, not LWIR backradiation.

  4. M E Emberson

    Isn’t limestone a product of dead coral reefs and other shell deposits in very ancient oceans ?. Limestone hill landscapes were once lagoons. Dying and bleaching coral is part of the recycling of carbonates on Earth. Climates go in cycles and water affects the formation of rock types and their erosion over and over again . Sand and coral and shells make up many kinds of rocks on Earth often changed by pressure to hard rocks like marble but essentially those same constitutents So dying reefs are part of the natural succession.Leave them alone,perhaps ?. They have served part of their purpose.

  5. Great Barrier Reef Warming, Coral Bleaching Driven By Cloud Radiative Forcing, Not Humans – Watts Up With That?

    […] From the NoTricksZone […]

  6. Great Barrier Reef Warming, Coral Bleaching Driven by Forced Cloud Radiation, Not Humans - Is It Emerging For That? - News7g

    […] From NoTricksZone […]

  7. Great Barrier Reef Warming, Coral Bleaching Driven by Cloud Radiative Forcing, Not Humans – Climate- Science.press

    […] From the NoTricksZone […]

  8. Great Barrier Reef Warming, Coral Bleaching Driven By Cloud Radiative Forcing, Not Humans – Watts Up With That? – ChicHue.com

    […] From the NoTricksZone […]

  9. Great Barrier Reef Warming, Coral Bleaching Driven By Cloud Radiative Forcing, Not Humans – Watts Up With That? - Blue Anon News

    […] From the NoTricksZone […]

  10. Tom0mason

    I said it over 10 years ago and I’ll say it again —
    “Never ascribe any change to human interference when natural cycles are the more likely cause.”
    Around that time I had a serious online argument with an Australian student. He maintained that the ‘bleaching’ was human made, I maintained that it was almost certainly just the effects of a natural cycle.

  11. Russell Seitz

    “It has taken over 260 years for the net total radiative forcing from CO2 to allegedly rise by a grand net total of 1.82 ”

    Stop right there Ken- you’re only three sentences in, and your innumeracy is starting to show.

    Do you really expect algae-hosting corals not to notice a 24/7 change in radiative forcing large as the energy flux in a brightly floodlit soccer stadium? It plainly overlaps the range of change from clouds.

  12. Great Barrier Reef Warming, Coral Bleaching Driven By Cloud Radiative Forcing, Not Humans - Western Highlights

    […] From the NoTricksZone […]

  13. Yonason

    I remember posting on this before…
    https://notrickszone.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/Coral-bleaching-during-the-Little-Ice-Age-Cedhagen-2021.jpg
    …but my comp has been down for months, and I can’t look up where.

    A little backstory; the artwork is by a fellow who went din in a diving bell, and drew and colored it by hand. Pretty impressive what we used to do, even without our current tools.

  14. CO2isLife

    Climate scientists need to start asking the most basic questions. The one and only mechanism by which CO2 can affect climate change is through the backradiation of 13 to 18 micron LWIR. That is it. Coral is bleaching. Visible radiation between 0.4 and 0.7 short wave visible radiation bleaches object. If LWIR would bleach clothes your dark closet would all hold bleached clothing. 15 Micron LWIR doesn’t penetrate water and it won’t bleach coral. That can be tested in a lab. Why wasn’t that done? Because it doesn’t support the narrative. Bleaching coral should be used as a proxy for an increase in incoming solar radiation and a source of the global warming.

  15. Weekly Climate and Energy News Roundup #482 – Watts Up With That?

    […] Great Barrier Reef Warming, Coral Bleaching Driven By Cloud Radiative Forcing, Not Humans […]

  16. Vetenskapen är inte stelnad! - Klimatupplysningen

    […] uppvärmningen har gjort att mycket av Stora Barriärrevet är dött eller döende. NoTricksZone berättar om ett forskningsresultat som ifrågasätter allt detta. Själva forskningspublikationen återfinns […]

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this. More information at our Data Privacy Policy

Close