California Climate Has Always Been Wild And Unstable – Even With Low Atmospheric CO2 – New Study Shows!

A new study has just come out in the journal Earth and Planetary Science Letters: Biomarkers reveal abrupt switches in hydroclimate during the last glacial in southern California.

Hat-tip: reader Mary Brown

It contradicts claims often made by global warming alarmists that the perceived California climate change is unusual, and that it is mostly due to man emitting “climate gases” into the atmosphere.

The new study finds that California’s climate has always been extreme roller coaster-like – even when atmospheric CO2 was at very low levels (ca. 200 ppm), as was the case during the last ice age.

Proxy evidence shows “temperatures varied during the last glacial, including extreme warmth”.

What follows is the paper’s abstract:

Reconstructions of past hydroclimate provide a means to understand precipitation responses to global ocean-atmosphere climate dynamics beyond the scope of that in the instrumental record.

Late glacial climate was characterized by abrupt variability in ice and ocean dynamics, however the implications for hydroclimate are not as well known. Here we present organic geochemical proxy evidence for precipitation isotopes based on plant leaf wax hydrogen isotopic compositions (δDwax) and temperature proxy evidence based upon the branched glycerol dialkyl glycerol tetraethers (brGDGTs), that derive from the membrane lipids of bacteria, each extracted from a sedimentary archive in Lake Elsinore, California spanning 32–9 ka. We add proxy evidence for vegetation and salinity from additional biomarker analyses and compare to prior pollen and sedimentological evidence from the same core.

Our record indicates a strong deglacial warming of 10 °C in Lake Elsinore (beginning at 14.5 ka) that accompanied a D-enrichment of precipitation of +90‰ and more C4 vegetation (12–10 ka), after a cold, wet and C3-dominated phase (20–14.5 ka), indicating winter-dominated precipitation during the Last Glacial Maximum and Heinrich Stadial 1. During the late glacial (32–20 ka) we find abrupt variability, with precipitation isotopic shifts (∼70‰) that are independent of temperature swings implicating changes in storm track, rather than local temperature as drivers of the precipitation isotope signal. Temperature is however not irrelevant for hydroclimate: we find extreme warmth at 29.4 ka and 26.8 ka, the latter coincident with existing reports of an extended dry period (27.5–25.5 ka), suggesting a long hot and dry interlude during the generally cooler glacial period. We compare δDwax with speleothem δ18O from Nevada, also within the winter-dominated precipitation region. Our results corroborate the Last Glacial Maximum and deglacial signals, and fill gaps revealing storm-track instability from 32–20 ka, however the pacing and magnitude of the biomarker signals merit cautious interpretation.”

Surprise, surprise – California’s climate has always been on the very wild side. Low CO2 did not tame it at all.

7 responses to “California Climate Has Always Been Wild And Unstable – Even With Low Atmospheric CO2 – New Study Shows!”

  1. Kurt in Switzerland

    Well that’s not particularly helpful (to the “Cause”)

  2. Yonason

    California’s drought history doesn’t support the hype.

    Yes, there can be a “perpetual” drought, but if it happens it won’t be out of the range of historical natural variation.

  3. John F. Hultquist

    implicating changes in storm track,

    What a great phrase.

  4. rah

    A land of extremes has extreme changes in weather in climate. Go figure.

    I mean really we’re talking about a state where I visited Furnace Creek, the place with the earths all time high surface temperature record that sits 58 m below sea level, played in snow in the San Bernardino mountains, and swam in the Pacific off Laguna Beach in a single day. BTW keep an eye on the Oroville Dam spillway this spring. It’s already been leaking again.

  5. Steve

    I love a sunburnt country
    a land of sweeping plains,
    of rugged mountain ranges
    of droughts and flooding rain.
    I love her far horizons
    I love her jewel sea
    her beauty and her terror
    The wide brow land for me!

    D. Mackeller
    Australia 1908

    Nothing has changed

  6. Weekly Climate and Energy News Roundup #355 | Watts Up With That?
  7. Weekly Climate and Energy News Roundup #355 - Sciencetells

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this. More information at our Data Privacy Policy