4 New Papers, One Alarm-Dispelling Conclusion: Future Sea Level Rise May NOT Threaten Islands After All

As reported in 4 separately-published papers, scientists have discovered a mechanism whereby islands can build themselves up naturally, thwarting the threat of sea level rise.  Tuck et al. (2019) affirm the implications of island building are profound, as it will offset existing scenarios of dramatic increases in island flooding.”

Earlier this year, Duvat (2019) identified a global trend in island shoreline net growth despite recent sea level rise.

The welcome news is that none of the islands larger than 10 ha – and just 1.2% of the 334 islands larger than 5 ha – have decreased in size since the 1980s. Nearly 90% of the world’s islands have been stable to expanding in coastal area during recent decades.

Image Source: Duvat, 2019

In four other new papers, 3 of them with Auckland University Ph.D candidate Megan E. Tuck as lead author, scientists have discovered a mechanism whereby islands have the capacity to “morphodynamically respond to rising sea level” via wave-driven “overwash processes”.

The implications are profound. The most concerning impacts of sea level rise may effectively be thwarted by natural processes and consequently “many islands are less vulnerable to inundation than currently perceived.”

Positive developments in marine science like this are indeed worth reporting in 4 papers and 3 separate scholarly journals within the same calendar year.

This good news also deserves much more coverage than the public is likely to see.

1. Tuck et al., 2019

“Here, we present evidence from physical model experiments of a reef island that demonstrates islands have the capability to morphodynamically respond to rising sea level through island accretion. Challenging outputs from existing models based on the assumption that islands are geomorphologically inert, results demonstrate that islands not only move laterally on reef platforms, but overwash processes provide a mechanism to build and maintain the freeboard of islands above sea level. Implications of island building are profound, as it will offset existing scenarios of dramatic increases in island flooding. Future predictive models must include the morphodynamic behavior of islands to better resolve flood impacts and future island vulnerability.”

2. Kench and Beetham, 2019

“Coral reef islands are unconsolidated deposits of reef-derived sand and gravel that are considered vulnerable to the impacts of global sea-level rise because of their low elevation (< 3 m) and exposure oceanic wave energy. Previous research has shown that sea-level rise will drive an increase in wave overtopping on reef island shorelines, which will be an increasing hazard for atoll island communities. Here, we show that wave overtopping on reef islands is a geomorphically important process that facilitates sediment deposition on the island surface and vertical building. Field evidence from 26 overwash deposits show that vertical island accretion can be driven by king tides, long-period swell, local storms, tropical cyclones and tsunami. Deposit depths ranged between 0.06–1.93 m and increased island elevations by between 4–400%. Recognition that overwash processes can contribute to vertical island building is instructive in considering the potential for islands to adjust to future increases in sea-level and to incorporate this critical morphodynamic response in future flood risk modelling for low islands.”

3. Tuck et al., 2019

“[R]esults show that the rate and magnitude of physical adjustment is strongly dependent on the rate and magnitude of sea-level rise and wave conditions. Results challenge existing models of future island susceptibility to wave driven flooding, demonstrating that washover processes can provide a mechanism to build and potentially maintain island freeboard above sea level. These insights highlight an urgent need to incorporate island morphodynamics into flood risk models in order to produce accurate assessments of future wave-driven flood risks and better resolve island vulnerability.”

4. Tuck et al., 2019

“Low-lying coral reef islands are considered extremely vulnerable to the impacts of climate change. However, future island morphodynamic adjustments in response to anticipated sea level rise and changing wave conditions are currently poorly resolved. Assertions of island vulnerability are based on outputs from flood risk models that simulate sea level rise on present day island topography despite evidence that many reef islands are highly dynamic landforms. Utilizing a physical modelling methodology, three experiment programs were undertaken to model gravel island morphodynamics in response to increasing sea level and changing wave conditions. Modelling outputs present new insights into the modes and styles of island change, primarily the first experimental evidence that reef islands can keep pace with sea level rise through island building driven by washover processes. Results suggest that many islands are less vulnerable to inundation than currently perceived and may endure on reef platforms despite sea level rise.”

6 responses to “4 New Papers, One Alarm-Dispelling Conclusion: Future Sea Level Rise May NOT Threaten Islands After All”

  1. Georg Thomas

    Sea level rises (the Deluge) – something must sink (dramatically).

    This is a “good” example how the green have largely destroyed environmental consciousness and discernment in our culture.

    The sacralisation of environmentalism has been achieved by inculcating people with very simple stories that accomplish at least two outcomes: they are alarming in a simplistically graphic way, make people feel they profoundly understand what (kind of apocalyptic drama) is going on, while convincing them that they are part of the righteous in a black-and-white world.

    Instead of genuinely caring about the relationship between man and nature, therefore accepting doubt and other strains that accompany real research efforts, people are no longer bothered with the complexities, roundabout and not so obvious aspects of natural phenomena — instead they are counting green rosaries.

    The job of “explaining” nature has been taken over by the green priests. The rest repeats the prayers.

    Popular environmentalism has become a largely vicarious exercise in religious dogmatism.

    It’s an easy way to be absolutely right, socially accepted, and disencumbered from the pain of having to think for oneself.

  2. John F. Hultquist

    Having been made multiple times several years ago, this seems like a good time to repeat:

    The land ice that melts more easily (rain has a good track record) is that at lower latitudes and lower elevations. This caused rapid post-glacial sea level rise (20,000 to about 8,000 years), but transitioned to a different – slower – situation. Since about 7,000 years ago the higher latitude and/or higher elevation ice makes for more difficult melting potential. Precipitation that falls as snow does not melt ice. Temperature close to freezing doesn’t melt ice very fast either.
    Bottom line: The easy ice and fast sea level rise are history.

  3. Patrick Healy

    Sea level rise?
    What, where?
    Can I have some proof please?

  4. Randall L Hunt

    Very well said, Georg Thomas!

  5. 4 New Papers, One Alarm-Dispelling Conclusion: Future Sea Level Rise May NOT Threaten Islands After All | Un hobby...

    […] K. Richard, November 4, 2019 in […]

  6. Weekly Local weather and Power Information Roundup #385 – Daily News

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this. More information at our Data Privacy Policy