As Climate Screamers Spread Alarm, Germany’s Long-Term Forest Fire Trend Has Declined

Help! There’s fire!

(Translated, edited by P. Gosselin)

It’s become an annual ritual. Every summer, when there has been little rain for a long time and unreasonable people set fire to forests, whether through intent or negligence, a solution comes into play: wind turbines.

Quaschning’s tweet in English:

There are people who obstruct wind turbines, supposedly in order to protect forests. But the opposite is true. Every obstructed wind turbine fires up the climate crisis with heat, drought and forest fires.”

(Image: Screenshot Twitter)

Old military grounds pose huge hazard to fire fighters

Of course, this is exactly what is happening with the current forest fire in Treuenbrietzen in Brandenburg, alarmists like Quaschning say. But, if you look very closely you will see that once again a forest area burned that had previously served as a military training area for several decades. Such areas are not easy to extinguish because firefighters put themselves in serious danger as remnants of ammunition are lying around everywhere. So the fire has an easy time when it can only be extinguished from a distance. Or, to put it another way, in forests without remnants of ammunition, firefighters would have fires under control quickly.

Nothing to do with temperature

What would help the forest is precipitation. Temperature is not the determining factor for forest fires, but the absence of rain. The forest would also be helped if people stopped handling fire in the forest during times of drought.

Yet we will read and hear the call for more wind power in the forests every time there is a forest fire from the likes of Big Wind lobbyists Volker Quaschning – and of course, without them addressing the forest floor contaminated with munitions. This has always been the case in recent years and has also been a topic in this blog. By the way, with the same protagonist as this year and almost word-same tweets.

Long-term downward trend

It is worth looking at the number of forest fires and the area of damage. The statistics of the Federal Office of Agriculture and Food are always released quite late (2021 is not yet available), but this “it’s getting worse” experience does not ring true up to 2020.

Three periods stand out: 1992, 2003, and 2018/2019.

2020 already returned to a low level. In 2019, there was a fire in Lübtheen (Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania). Also there on a former military training area. Salvage tanks of the Bundeswehr had to move in and former employees of the site were located who still had ammunition maps. Only then could the fire be extinguished. There was also a fire in Jüterbog (Brandenburg) and, once again, on a military training area there as well. Both fires were very difficult to extinguish. Without the danger posed by the munitions, such fires could be controlled by local fire departments. However, this does not make a very good news story.

Number of forest fires and area burned in hectares. (Chart: Screenshot

6 responses to “As Climate Screamers Spread Alarm, Germany’s Long-Term Forest Fire Trend Has Declined”

  1. John Hultquist

    Fire needs fuel, oxygen, and an ignition.
    Except for lightning strikes, there is usually human involvement
    in the ignition part – mostly not intentional.
    Ignition is more difficult when precipitation is recent.
    That also means grasslands and forests produce more fuel.

  2. The Atmosphere Guy

    There is a factor that is commonly overlooked in the ignition of forest fires. Large scale on-shore wind farms in many parts of the world are normally located on hilltops, many of which are in densely forested regions. High voltage cables between individual units and thence out to the grid are routed via paths cut through the forested areas. Underground routing is normally impractical in these areas. It does not take a lot for debris, branches and so on to be blown against the cables or the wires themselves to be brought down. The consequences are inevitable and far more common than is admitted.

  3. dm

    So, to prevent climate change from burning up forests, let’s denude forests to erect wind turbine and solar plantations as well as to fuel wood-fired generating stations (like Drax in the UK).

    Scotty, beam climate alarmists to another realm. There is no sign of intelligence amongst them.

  4. Richard Greene

    Up to 90% of fires are caused by humans.
    I can’t see why a few tenths of a degree of warming
    would change human behavior.
    Global warming has been accompanied by more rainfall.
    Changes in rainfall could affect acres burned.

    If there is a season when fuel is dry, then
    a few tenths of a degree warmer can’t make
    the already dry brush any drier.

    I see no logical connection between acres burned
    and tiny changes in the average temperature,
    especially with most of the warming at night (TMIN).

    1. dm

      “…90% of fires are caused by humans.” Anthropogenic warming!!!

  5. Richard Greene

    I like Climate Howlers better than climate screamers.
    Howlers reminds me of a neighborhood dog that howls when he hears a fire siren or police siren. The Climate Howlers howl every time they read an article predicting climate doom. Especially ff it starts with “Scientists say”.

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this. More information at our Data Privacy Policy