German ARD Meteorologist: “Can’t Blame Climate Change” For This Year’s Hurricanes… “Many Factors”

Last Tuesday morning German flagship ARD public television meteorologist Donald Bäcker surprised some climate-realist viewers here with a very level-headed look at the factors behind hurricane development.

I use the word “surprise” here because the massive German public media system are generally devout warmists and vigilant gatekeepers against skeptic views. Open discussion here means discussion only among adherents and the like-minded. Anyone with a dissident view usually is branded and excluded.

Before telling viewers the day’s forecast for Germany, Bäcker gave some background information on the current hurricane situation during the first 42 seconds of the clip.


German ARD public television meteorologist Donald Bäcker tells viewers many factors are behind hurricanes, and not just climate change. Image cropped from ARD moma here.

He begins the segment by reminding us that there is “still a large need regarding research on climate and weather“, adding:

We can of course make everything really easy and say the powerful hurricanes in the current season are caused by climate change. But you just can’t do that. With this you cannot explain the years 2008 – 2015, as during this period there were practically no strong hurricanes in the Caribbean region. It has to do with a number of factors, among them ocean currents are to blame, and you need triggering factors. These are the so-called easterlies.”

Bäcker then explained how this year all the factors are in place and the conditions for producing hurricanes are “optimal”. A refreshingly non-dogmatic analysis, and so hats off to the ARD in this one particular case.

Politics, or science?

Of course, it didn’t take long for an alarmist rebuttal to be made two days later. And what better person to provide it than a “scientist” from the ultra-alarmist, politically activist Potsdam Institute for Climate Research: Manfred Stock.

A visibly desperate Stock tells viewers that man is mostly responsible for the terrible hurricanes and insists that the PIK scientists have the data to show it. Stock warns that we are at a crossroads (again) and that unless we change our ways quickly and drastically, we are going to see a catastrophe.

Stock added that hurricanes have become worse since 1980. But here he failed to explain the lack of hurricanes in the Caribbean from 2008 – 2015 mentioned by Bäcker and the overall downward trend of the past 100 years.

When it comes to hurricanes, and number of other climate and weather issues, the PIK alarmists have a very pronounced habit of forgetting things and misleading the public.

Stefan Rahmstorf’s amnesia (or fraud?)

For example just days ago Stefan Rahmstorf of the PIK claimed that this year’s spate of hurricanes were “unprecedented” – a statement I had a hard time believing. So I asked hurricane expert Philipp Klotzbach at Twitter about this. He replied:

The PIK seems to have a big problem with data selection and processing. Moreover, it’s always either we have to drastically change how we live, and quickly, or we will see planetary disaster. It’s the old playbook used by charlatans again and again throughout the history of civilization.


6 responses to “German ARD Meteorologist: “Can’t Blame Climate Change” For This Year’s Hurricanes… “Many Factors””

  1. A C Osborn

    These latest Hurricanes have been way over hyped.
    The actual Ground based wind values have been nothing like the “Satellite Modelled” values being banded about by Scientists, the MSM and anybody involved in the Hurricane’s paths.


    Well no surprise here.
    The Germans do have memory problems at times for really critical events and facts. They got it wrong with their scientific facts about the Jew and Aryans.
    But they bungled along anyway convincing themselves of the rightness of their politically inspired but totally unsupported “scientific” evidence e of the inferiors of the Jew and superiority of the Master Race.
    This is more of the same These sir-down-to-pee girly men socialists are a bigger problem than climate change.

    1. Fred Streeter

      And there you go, bungling along, convincing yourself that a lack of personal hygiene makes you superior to ‘The German Socialist’.

    2. tom0mason


      You start your rant with the phrase “The Germans”, this to me signals that what ever [-snip. Strange, totally unsubstantiated accusation you make here. Referring to people who are German citizens as Germans is not racist. -PG]

      1. tom0mason

        Sorry mod if I got that mixed up, however I do feel that people who start the comment by painting an entire group of people as one complete entity smells badly of racism to me.
        I looks so much to me as a comment trying to excite a national ‘them’ and ‘us’ mentality. I’m sure (as I have witnessed) most German people have learned and have understanding of their past and have move on from it.

  3. RAH

    “German ARD Meteorologist: “Can’t Blame Climate Change” For This Year’s Hurricanes… “Many Factors””

    That hasn’t stopped some from trying. Even NOAA is claiming that the rains Harvey brought to the Houston area were “unnatural”.

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this. More information at our Data Privacy Policy